Bill, to borrow the words of Everet in
Oh Brother, Where Art Thou, you seem to be in a "geographical oddity--two weeks from everywhere"--only in your case you're about an hour and change from everywhere that fencers hang out.
If that's not too far, then you're in luck. There are several clubs in the Cleveland-Akron-Canton corridor, and there are several clubs in and around Pittsburgh.
Go to
www.usfencing.org and click in the upper left on "New to Fencing?". Then go to "Where can I fence?". The map contains links to the sections and divisions, where clubs will be listed.
The two divisions you'd be interested in are the Northern Ohio Division of the Great Lakes Section (Cleveland area) and the Western Pennsylvania Division of the Mid-Atlantic Section (Pittsburgh area).
Or you could get some friends together and start your own club. Talk to the local YMCA about offering a class; you don't have to be a registered coach to teach the basics of footwork or bladework, which I'm sure you remember.
Did you do your college fencing at U of D Mercy?