topleft topright

Closed Thread
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 28
  1. #1
    Senior Member Array
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Location
    The periphery
    Posts
    2,053

    How do you define a "Strong" Local Tournament?

    Because I'm a dork, I created the attached Excel Workbook.

    There is one sheet with data (entries from our memorial day tournament), courtesy of FRED: http://askfred.net/Events/moreInfo.p...nament_id=1335

    I find the numbers interesting. To answer the question, "Which tournament of the three is the strongest?" One would, quite obviously, need to decide what determines "strength." Each of the three tournaments could be considered the strongest in its own right, depending on the criteria selected.

    Is it Number of Classified Fencers? Percentage of Classified Fencers? Percentage of Div I eligible Fencers? Percentage of A/B Fencers?

    I just thought the numbers were interesting, and thought I'd share... comment away.

    -w
    Last edited by DJ Apostrophe; 02-21-2008 at 11:34 PM.

  2. #2
    Senior Member Array seak's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Cambridge
    Posts
    1,559

    to take it even further

    To take it even further, I decided to devise a (very) simple math formula to determine strenght. In this "formula" each A = 6 points each B = 5 so on so forth and each U = 1. This allows for size and strenght to be measured as well as relative strenght i.e. an A is better then a B. Therefore in this tournament foil = 107, sabre = 116 and epee = 164, hence epee is the strongest.

    Wow that was pretty dorky

  3. #3
    Senior Member Array
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    away
    Posts
    4,514
    Quote Originally Posted by seak
    ...hence epee is the strongest.
    ... but you have not weighted for ratings between weapons. Unless you are saying that a sabre A is as easy to get as an epee A .

    edit;

    so if you compare the % of each letter rating in each event to (god knows how accurate) rating numbers I found here it looks like Sabre is strongest;

    Sabre 252.29
    Epee 131.35
    Foil 93.24

    (using the same A=6 etc but weighting for difference from 'normal' for each weapon).
    au revoir

  4. #4
    Fencing Expert Array oiuyt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Location
    Pennsauken, NJ
    Posts
    11,810
    Quote Originally Posted by keith
    ... but you have not weighted for ratings between weapons. Unless you are saying that a sabre A is as easy to get as an epee A ;).
    Obviously it's easier, I've earned my sabre A 5 times, have yet to earn it once in epee, despite having fenced epee for close to twice as long... :)

    -B
    "Oh but you can't expect to wield supreme executive power just because some watery tart threw a sword at you!"

  5. #5
    Senior Member Array epeemike81's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2001
    Location
    Chestnut Hill, MA
    Posts
    4,771
    Quote Originally Posted by seak
    To take it even further, I decided to devise a (very) simple math formula to determine strenght. In this "formula" each A = 6 points each B = 5 so on so forth and each U = 1. This allows for size and strenght to be measured as well as relative strenght i.e. an A is better then a B. Therefore in this tournament foil = 107, sabre = 116 and epee = 164, hence epee is the strongest.

    Wow that was pretty dorky
    And epee wins due simply to having 15 more people allowed to enter.

    so, does size make a competition inherently stronger?

    -m

  6. #6
    Senior Member Array epeemike81's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2001
    Location
    Chestnut Hill, MA
    Posts
    4,771
    Quote Originally Posted by keith
    ... but you have not weighted for ratings between weapons. Unless you are saying that a sabre A is as easy to get as an epee A .

    edit;

    so if you compare the % of each letter rating in each event to (god knows how accurate) rating numbers I found here it looks like Sabre is strongest;

    Sabre 252.29
    Epee 131.35
    Foil 93.24

    (using the same A=6 etc but weighting for difference from 'normal' for each weapon).
    much more reasonable.

    -m

  7. #7
    Senior Member Array
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Posts
    1,233
    Greetings Keith,
    Well since there are more A fencers in epee it stands to reason that they are more available, and therefor easier to get.

    Ofcourse a rating only says you were so good ONCE, not how good you will be today.
    TD

    Quote Originally Posted by keith
    ... but you have not weighted for ratings between weapons. Unless you are saying that a sabre A is as easy to get as an epee A .

  8. #8
    Senior Member Array
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Posts
    1,233
    Greetings oiuyt,
    Or it could be that you realize that sabre is better thqn epee, so you try harder when you fence it

    Terry

    Quote Originally Posted by oiuyt
    Obviously it's easier, I've earned my sabre A 5 times, have yet to earn it once in epee, despite having fenced epee for close to twice as long...

    -B

  9. #9
    Moderator Array
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    11,972
    Or "longer" doesn't translate to "as often" directly.

  10. #10
    Senior Member Array chiz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2003
    Location
    Tennessee
    Posts
    203
    Quote Originally Posted by DJ Apostrophe
    /url]

    I find the numbers interesting. To answer the question, "Which tournament of the three is the strongest?" One would, quite obviously, need to decide what determines "strength." Each of the three tournaments could be considered the strongest in its own right, depending on the criteria selected.

    Is it Number of Classified Fencers? Percentage of Classified Fencers? Percentage of Div I eligible Fencers? Percentage of A/B Fencers?

    I just thought the numbers were interesting, and thought I'd share... comment away.-w
    I think this will work. Go to Sciurus-Rex’s thread “Seeding question: What is the "index" number?” IanSerotkin has a range of index number values for seeding polls. Take the inverse of all the index numbers, add them and take an average, the closest to 1 is the strongest. You may want to give consideration for the number of A to B, A to C, A to D, and etc.

    Chiz

  11. #11
    Senior Member Array
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    away
    Posts
    4,514
    Quote Originally Posted by DJ Apostrophe
    Is it Number of Classified Fencers? Percentage of Classified Fencers? Percentage of Div I eligible Fencers? Percentage of A/B Fencers?
    The interesting number, for advertising purposes, might be the relative strength factor against other regional open events.

    The 'which weapon was harder to win' pissing match is all good fun but knowing that such an such an event is the strongest in the calender might help draw more entrants. Or for fencers suffering competition phobia knowing that a certain event while open, is relatively weak, might be useful. Of course I'm not sure a detailed statistical analysis is required to work that out

    back to the micturition.
    au revoir

  12. #12
    Moderator Array
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    11,972
    I can't think of a tournament in this region which has had a sabre event which approached the epee event with one exception, the 2004 Rose Condon (A2 in each event, but with a lot more As in epee). So by definition any epee event around here will be stronger, but on the other hand, any epee event around here which doesn't make A4 can look a little anemic, whereas any sabre event which makes B2 is near or in the top tier of regional sabre.

  13. #13
    Fencing Expert Array oiuyt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Location
    Pennsauken, NJ
    Posts
    11,810
    Quote Originally Posted by KD5MDK
    Or "longer" doesn't translate to "as often" directly.
    I've been in more A-rated epee tournaments than A-rated sabre tournaments.

    That said, of course you are correct. As I've improved (in both epee and sabre) the proportion of tournaments that I've entered has shifted well to the sabre end of the spectrum.

    Quote Originally Posted by notalent
    Or it could be that you realize that sabre is better thqn epee, so you try harder when you fence it
    Might have something here... :)

    Quote Originally Posted by keith
    but knowing that such an such an event is the strongest in the calender might help draw more entrants.
    Ah, but in this case there are pre-set limits on the size of the fields. Epee and sabre are already full, foil had 1 remaining slot open last time I checked. I suspect that at some point in the next four months they will all become full without any additional speculation on which is the strongest. :)

    Query for the PdF people: Why do sabre/foil have limits of 36 rather than 39?

    -B
    ps just as a side note, despite my classifications, I strongly believe that ME is the easiet weapon in which to obtain an A classification.
    "Oh but you can't expect to wield supreme executive power just because some watery tart threw a sword at you!"

  14. #14
    Moderator Array
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    11,972
    Because they LOVE EPEE and HATE the rest of us.

  15. #15
    Senior Member Array rcmatthews's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Paris, France
    Posts
    1,155
    Quote Originally Posted by KD5MDK
    I can't think of a tournament in this region which has had a sabre event which approached the epee event with one exception, the 2004 Rose Condon (A2 in each event, but with a lot more As in epee). So by definition any epee event around here will be stronger, but on the other hand, any epee event around here which doesn't make A4 can look a little anemic, whereas any sabre event which makes B2 is near or in the top tier of regional sabre.
    I guess it depends on what you consider the region. In the southwest section, in 2004, CCO was also an A2 in sabre, with an arguably stronger field than the Rose. However since I am on the boundaries of the Southwest section, I consider Atlanta to be in my region, and the strongest sabre tournaments for me are there. They also had an A4 this summer, and in sabre, I doubt that happens much outside of NACs
    Ich steige ab, Hab keine Zeit, Muss jetzt zu den anderen Pferden, Wollen auch geritten werden

    C'est pas la chute, c'est l'atterrissage.

  16. #16
    Senior Member Array MyrddinsPrecint's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Location
    Boston
    Posts
    5,724
    Blog Entries
    37
    Quote Originally Posted by keith
    The interesting number, for advertising purposes, might be the relative strength factor against other regional open events.

    The 'which weapon was harder to win' pissing match is all good fun but knowing that such an such an event is the strongest in the calender might help draw more entrants. Or for fencers suffering competition phobia knowing that a certain event while open, is relatively weak, might be useful. Of course I'm not sure a detailed statistical analysis is required to work that out

    back to the micturition.

    this is a good point. it's relitively difficult to determine the ease of getting an A in sabre vs. epee-- there is some evidence that leads one in a certain direction, but it's not necessarily accurate. it's much easier to determine the ease of getting an A in sabre at this event compared to getting an A in sabre at the Pomme de Terre.

    the question "how do you define a strong event" is, in fact, a good question. the problem is that the data provided, in itself, doesn't provide a good statistical base for anything.


  17. #17
    Fencing Expert Array oiuyt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Location
    Pennsauken, NJ
    Posts
    11,810
    Quote Originally Posted by MyrddinsPrecint
    it's much easier to determine the ease of getting an A in sabre at this event compared to getting an A in sabre at the Pomme de Terre.
    Well, the Memorial Day tournament has been A-level every year it has been run (so far just last year, but with an expectation that this will continue).

    Let's look at the Pomme. Open MS hasn't been an A event since 2003. Looking through results I think that might be the only time it has ever been an A event. Granted that includes such rediculousness as 2004 where the 2 A's present made it to the gold medal bout, but 10 of 11 B's failed to make the round of 8. So I'd say, historically, it's been significantly harder to earn a sabre A at the Pomme. :)

    edit: on the other hand, Open Women's Sabre WAS an A event at the Pomme last year.

    -B
    "Oh but you can't expect to wield supreme executive power just because some watery tart threw a sword at you!"

  18. #18
    Member Array alewive's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    New England
    Posts
    77
    Question here...being a round robin event, does it follow the same age restrictions discussed in other threads pertaining to opens? Looking at the preregs, I see at least one youngster (Y-12/U) that I know of in there.

    While we know age doesn't always relate to ability, in terms of tournament strength, there's obviously a range of both ages and abilities here (a 12-yr-old U fencing an A over twice his age). Which may very well be the point of the r/r format?...give everyone a shot? No question this will be a strong event; I'm just curious, as I don't have much experience with this format.

  19. #19
    Senior Member Array MyrddinsPrecint's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Location
    Boston
    Posts
    5,724
    Blog Entries
    37
    Quote Originally Posted by alewive
    Question here...being a round robin event, does it follow the same age restrictions discussed in other threads pertaining to opens? Looking at the preregs, I see at least one youngster (Y-12/U) that I know of in there.

    While we know age doesn't always relate to ability, in terms of tournament strength, there's obviously a range of both ages and abilities here (a 12-yr-old U fencing an A over twice his age). Which may very well be the point of the r/r format?...give everyone a shot? No question this will be a strong event; I'm just curious, as I don't have much experience with this format.

    one justification is that it's an amazing amount of fun.

    another is that it's a GREAT event for kids near the end of high school to go to, because it closely mimics a lot of collegiate fencing, where you're fencing 5 touch bouts ALL DAY, and if you don't treat every bout as if it matters, you do horribly.

    did i mention it's fun?


    and by fun, i mean it in a very masochistic way, because i couldn't walk after my second bout of the day last year.


    (PS, someone make me withdraw this year if that happens again??)

  20. #20
    Senior Member Array fencerbill's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    near Boston
    Posts
    3,772
    Quote Originally Posted by oiuyt
    Obviously it's easier, I've earned my sabre A 5 times, have yet to earn it once in epee, despite having fenced epee for close to twice as long...

    -B
    I attribute that to your agility.

    Simplistically, You can excel in Epee due to your hand.

    For Sabre you need legs.

    Both need timing.

    And as you age, your hand can hold up longer than your legs can.

    (It is tough turning 70)
    Whoopee! My avatar is back.

Similar Threads

  1. Moving the USFA Forward
    By dknj in forum Fencing Discussion
    Replies: 139
    Last Post: 12-22-2005, 01:14 AM
  2. [CFML] Russ Heggen Memorial Tournament results
    By Michael Heggen in forum Classical Fencing Mailing List
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 04-11-2005, 03:00 PM
  3. Replies: 31
    Last Post: 03-31-2005, 04:41 PM
  4. [CFML] SCF Fall Tournament results
    By Michael Heggen in forum Classical Fencing Mailing List
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11-24-2004, 08:00 PM
  5. Local Tournament in San Antonio
    By Princess in forum Tournaments and Camps
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 07-09-2003, 12:59 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30