Extra finger(s)

1. D+F+P=Hadouken!,
2. The Terran

Extra Toe(s)

1. D+F+P=Hadouken!

I'm normal...you freak!

1. Boo Boo,
2. D+F+P=Hadouken!,
3. DE_Strip_Tease,
4. DJ Apostrophe,
5. downunder,
6. Frater_Frag,
7. Go? Fencing?,
8. KShan5[PrFC],
9. melihop,
10. Morion,
11. Moses,
12. mrbiggs,
13. needle,
14. ojc,
15. rory,
16. Saber-Psycho,
17. seven6ty,
18. SFfencer,
19. sjpfencer220,
20. teefeelee,
21. telkanuru,
22. The Mormegil,
23. TitaniuM,
24. TrainingDummy,
25. VERITAS

I was born with some other oddity, that I will promtly list in my response.

1. cornflower,
2. D+F+P=Hadouken!,
3. epeeisky,
4. fencergal33,
5. foily,
6. KD5MDK,
7. Monash_Armourer,
8. Zasha